Tips for School Leaders in a Post-Net Neutrality World

  • 01/09/18

Marie Bierede

On December 14, 2017, the FCC voted to rescind the fairly young Net Neutrality protections put into place two years ago. The purpose of these rules was to prevent Internet Service Providers from giving preferential treatment to some parts of the Internet over others with regard to blocking or slowing the delivery of content. Although ISPs have indicated that they are not planning to degrade service to schools and districts, some educators are viewing these assurances with some skepticism, noting that things can change quickly. This article from EdSurge lists numerous ways in which education might be impacted by the loss of Net Neutrality. As Douglas Casey, Executive Director Connecticut Commission for Educational Technology points out, there are two cases. “We should consider the likely charges (Scenario A) to end users (e.g., a district paying a premium for G Suite access from its ISP) as well as (Scenario B) to content providers (that same ISP charging Google for fast delivery to districts). Both types of charges can and likely will take place.”

There is more that districts can do to address Scenario A. Ron Reyer, Director of Technology Services at Bethel Park School District, Penn., shares this language that his district has used in RFPs with ISPs in order to get Net Neutrality provisions in their contract:

  • Service Level Agreement - RWAN Transport Service, Dedicated Internet Access Service and Internet2 Transport

Does the Vendor have Service Level Agreement terms and conditions? If so, what are they? What are the proposed metrics and measurement intervals? What mechanisms are used to monitor service (both historical and real-time) to evaluate whether the SLA provisions have been met or not been met?  For commodity Internet access service, does the SLA include the entire complement of Internet traffic including all protocols regardless of whether traversing IPv4 or IPv6? 

  • Quality of Service - Dedicated Internet Access Service and Internet2 Transport

Is the Vendor willing to provide written assurance that there will be no preferential treatment for or against any specific type of traffic based on port, protocol, site origination, site destination, time of day? 

For the districts that are fortunate enough to have access to a statewide Research and Education Network (REN), they can gain the advantages of their bargaining power. RENs, with their large size, are in a much better position to negotiate with their ISPs for net-neutral treatment.

The Quilt, a national coalition of Research and Education Networks, made the following statement: “RENs are committed to making all of the Internet available to all users, and use a number of techniques to ensure the Internet performs well for users and does not limit
access to services and content they desire.“ With RENs and ISPs that sign up to service level agreements, there are still issues of what happens to traffic once it leaves that ISP’s network - at that point, they are no longer capable of making guarantees.

Douglas Casey’s Scenario B also remains problematic. Small or new or innovative education technology companies that depend on the Internet may not be able to afford to compete with the incumbents if ISPs charge them a premium to avoid having traffic throttled. This could limit access for districts to new offerings and have a chilling effect on innovation. For now, district leaders see the loss of Net Neutrality as potentially troubling, but only time will tell how the impact will evolve for our education system.

About Marie Bierede

Marie Bjerede is a nationally recognized authority on mobile learning, the Founder of e-Mergents, and a 25-year veteran executive leader in high-tech and wireless communication development. Bjerede advises schools, startups, and technology leaders on the products, practices, and platforms that enable and scale authentic learning and teaching with technology. Bjerede is the Principal for CoSN's Leadership for Mobile Learning (LML) and Smart Education Networks by Design (SEND) initiatives.

Featured

  • Shaping Campus Identity: The Crucial Role of Landscape Architecture in Campus Design

    Landscape architecture plays a crucial role in shaping the overall experience, functionality, and identity of college and university campuses. The design and layout of outdoor spaces influence everything from the interactions between students to the ease with which people navigate the campus. A thoughtfully designed campus provides not only a functional environment for daily activities but also a space that inspires academic success and fosters personal growth.

  • bar graph with the bars made out of abstract cinder blocks and other construction materials

    Spaces4Learning 2025 Trends in K–12: Materials & Construction

    With 2025 well underway, it’s time to take a look at some broader trends submitted by you, our Spaces4Learning readership. We asked for your thoughts on topics like classroom design, health & safety, materials & construction, and technology in both K–12 and higher-education environments. Below is a roundup of 2025 trends in K–12 materials and construction from the experts in the trenches.

  • Designing a Performing Arts Center from a PE Perspective

    Designing a top-tier performing arts facility for a high school is a complex endeavor that demands a delicate balance between advanced technical specifications and practical budget considerations. Nevertheless, it represents a crucial initiative that enriches educational and community engagements.

  • Fellowes Launches New Textile Collection

    Fellowes Contract Interiors recently partnered with Momentum Textiles & Wallcoverings to launch a new line of high-end-design, cost-effective textiles, according to a news release. Part of Momentum Textiles’ Kickstart collection, the new selection offers high-quality and versatile textiles for both smaller budgets and the early design phase of larger projects.