School Lighting: Think Relight, Not Just Relamp

The average cost of electricity rose more than 40 percent over the last 10 years, according to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), presenting a rising cost for today’s educational institutions. As a result, many colleges and universities are exploring ways to improve financial performance by investing in energy-efficient building systems such as lighting, which accounts for about one-fourth of the average school’s electricity costs.

The current stock of more than 83,000 college and university buildings presents significant opportunities to save energy and “go green” by improving environmental sustainability. Looking at all schools, including K–12 and postsecondary, 63 percent of floor space was built before 1980, of which 40 percent has never been renovated, according to DOE. These schools are likely overlighted using obsolete lighting technologies such as T12 fluorescent lamps, which are being phased out by DOE regulation starting in July 2012 (with some exceptions) and fluorescent magnetic ballasts (ballasts being devices required to start and operate fluorescent lamps), which will complete their phase-out by July 2010; again, with some exceptions.

The simplest change involves replacing these lamps and ballasts with more efficient T8 lamps and electronic ballasts, while keeping the same light fixtures and layout, resulting in up to 48 percent energy savings, according to the National Lighting Bureau.
Don’t Make Inappropriate Lighting Worse
But this can be a serious mistake. Simply changing older light fixtures can make an inappropriate lighting design even worse, and takes student visual comfort out of the decision-making process. As light exists for people, not buildings, the goal should be not only to optimize financial performance, but student performance as well.

Why is this important? Some 80 percent of human impressions of the world are generated by vision. Light makes sight, and is essentially a commodity. Lighting, however, affects visual comfort and perception, and therefore should be treated as an asset. As an example, consider the positive effects of properly designed daylighting. In one study conducted in 1999 by Heschong Mahone Group on behalf of PG&E, students with access to the most daylighting in their classrooms in one K–12 district progressed 20 percent faster on math tests and 26 percent on reading tests in one year than those with the least. In two other districts, students in classrooms with the most daylighting were found to have seven to 18 percent higher scores than those with the least.
Relight Instead of Relamp
Given the importance of good lighting, institutions should consider relight options instead of just relamping in order to improve lighting quality in their facilities, while generating even higher energy savings and flexibility by incorporating efficient design and lighting controls. A relight involves upgrading existing fixtures’ internal components with relight assemblies containing fewer, longer-life lamps that reduce energy usage by as much as 67 percent. Other lighting upgrade options are one-to-one replacement of older recessed fixtures with higher-performing alternatives, or a fresh design involving suspended indirect/direct fixtures based on lighting best practices. Existing classrooms, after all, deserve the same advantages of good design as new buildings. If the classroom features teaching methods utilizing computers and multimedia technologies, a relight is simply essential.
Best Practice for Good Lighting

What is best practice for lighting today’s classrooms? What is good lighting?

The Collaborative for High Performance Schools (CHPS) incorporates lighting best practice into its rating system, which recognizes learning environments that are healthy, comfortable, efficient, and easy to operate and maintain. For example, CHPS encourages indirect/direct lighting and giving instructors the ability to adjust lighting conditions for A/V presentations and whiteboard teaching with suitable light levels on desktops and whiteboard.

Many older classroom facilities are lighted using recessed parabolic lighting fixtures. This type of lighting can create harsh shadows and a dim atmosphere. Combining direct and indirect distribution, which places uniform, diffuse illumination on walls and ceilings, can improve visual comfort (reduced glare, eyestrain, harsh shadows) and facial recognition while making the space feel larger, brighter, more open. The addition of high-color-rendering fluorescent lamps, meanwhile, will make the classroom appear more visually vibrant.
Trends to Watch
Two of the “six trends to watch” identified in America’s Digital Schools 2008 include the implementation of 1:1 computerized classrooms and the adoption of interactive whiteboards. Many classrooms now use computers and multimedia teaching tools, with the latter technology certain to accelerate rapidly in significance with future introduction of document cameras that can render augmented reality images. This has resulted in demand for lighting that is adjustable in terms of light output to improve image visibility. Lighting originally designed for black chalkboards and a single horizontal task plane is clearly inadequate for these environments.

While PIER 4.5 was revolutionary several years ago, today even this cutting-edge design is considered somewhat limited. Manufacturers have already begun to move beyond PIER 4.5, offering not just a few (as in the case of PIER’s good, better, best approach), but hundreds of options providing a choice of aesthetics, light distribution, lamping, efficiency, control, and economics to match the requirements of virtually any learning application. A number of manufacturers offer various choices of classroom solutions as integrated lighting and controls packages with plug-and-play wiring and all components clearly labeled for easy installation in an existing or new facility. Many are based on indirect/direct lighting — as this enables separate control of the uplight and downlight components of the fixture with associated switching flexibility — but some are not.

For example, in some spaces, such as classrooms with lower ceiling heights, suspended indirect/direct lighting may not be practical. As an alternative, specially designed “volumetric” distribution recessed T8 and T5 light fixtures are available that distribute light horizontally as well as downward, but do not produce excessive brightness at high angles that can cause direct glare. The result is improved illumination on walls and lighting conditions that foster visual comfort using the same principles as indirect/direct lighting. The fixtures typically replace existing recessed fixtures on a one-for-one basis, slashing energy consumption by up to 60 to 67 percent while producing required light levels using up to 50 percent fewer lamps. Lower energy use is not only better for the operating budget, but also promotes sustainability. A typical 50-room lighting upgrade can save up to $113,000 through the course of 15 years, and have the same environment impact of planting up to 1,800 trees. 
Additional Options
Meanwhile, other controls such as dimming and daylight harvesting control can be integrated into the indirect/direct or recessed system to increase flexibility and savings, while control strategies can extend beyond the classroom across the entire building or campus, with remote centralized control from a single operator workstation.

School lighting traditionally has been about putting enough light on desks; now it is about providing an effective and comfortable total visual environment. Lighting fixture manufacturers offer a large palette of solutions providing many ways to achieve high levels of lighting quality, efficiency, and flexibility that ties in perfectly with financial performance and sustainability impact from lighting upgrades for existing facilities.
Monik Mehra is director of Vertical Marketing for Education Facilities Lighting at Acuity Brands Lighting and Controls, which represents key brands such as Lithonia, Peerless, Holophane, LC&D, and Sensor Switch. For more information about lighting, please contact [email protected]