Higher Education Leaders Agree That Good Planning Is Important But Most Don't Do It Well, Survey Reveals

Succeeding at PlanningANN ARBOR, MI – A survey on college and university planning revealed that higher education leaders agree that good planning is crucial to an institution's long-term success but there is also room for improvement, according to a recent survey by the Society for College and University Planning (SCUP), an international association that develops individual and organizational planning capacities for higher education.
The survey results are available for free at www.scup.org/2015planningsurvey.

In June 2015, the society, with assistance from Ann Arbor-based Baker Strategy Group, emailed a survey to more than 94,000 higher education professionals in the United States. The survey asked about planning practices on the respondent’s campuses and their familiarity with the society.

The survey attracted responses from higher education leaders involved in academic and strategic planning as well as leaders active in other areas of institutional planning. Their input provided insights on what is and is not going well in planning across higher education institutions. Most respondents understood and agreed with the notion that good planning is an important contributor to the success of the institution but they gave their senior leadership failing grades when it came to planning.

Areas that go relatively well in the planning process on campus, according to the survey, include creating awareness of the need to plan and the planning process, incorporating feedback, identifying the right people to participate in the planning process, and producing a plan that can be implemented.

Areas of relative difficulty include using a common planning vocabulary, creating transparency, identifying resource strategies, and structuring planning documents.

“Integrated planning is critical in preparing for the future of higher education,” says Nicholas R. Santilli, chair of the SCUP Board of Directors and associate provost for accreditation & institutional effectiveness and professor of psychology at John Carroll University. “Higher education leaders must address complex challenges and envision new forms of collaboration. Good planning bears tremendous fruit, but it can be a difficult process to conduct and involves overcoming numerous challenges for successful execution. To succeed in planning, campus leaders should focus efforts on the areas that, if improved, would have the largest impact on overall planning success.”

The survey results also revealed seven factors that are closely related to overall success in planning for colleges and universities, including (1) emphasize planning and create a "culture of planning" on the campus, (2) provide training on planning, (3) define effectiveness, (4) integrate planning across the campus (or across multiple campuses), (5) agree on planning priorities, (6) be agile, and (7) manage change.

Not all roles at the institution have the same perspective on current planning effectiveness. Leaders engaged in broad campus planning have a higher view of their institution's planning, while those involved in academics and student services tend to have a lower view of overall planning at the institution. Respondents who spend more time on planning give higher ratings, suggesting that the integration of part-time planners is where the challenge lies.

Featured

  • Enjoy Tax and Energy Savings with the Right Ceiling Solutions

    Thanks to recent innovations pairing mineral fiber ceiling panels with phase change material technology (PCM), architects, designers, facility managers, and other key players in construction and renovation projects are re-thinking the role ceilings play in supporting environmental objectives—especially energy savings.

  • AP Construction Breaks Ground on Two Projects for Austin ISD

    Adolfson & Peterson Construction (AP) recently announced that it has broken ground on two renovation projects for the Austin Independent School District, according to a news release. The work at McCallum and Anderson High Schools totals 97,350 square feet and is scheduled for completion in January 2027.

  • i-PRO, NovoTrax Partner for New School Emergency Response Solution

    i-PRO Americas, Inc., which manufactures edge computing cameras, recently announced a partnership with NovoTrax, provider of end-to-end life safety and mass notification solutions, to address gaps in emergency response workflows at K–12 schools, according to a news release.

  • Thomas F. Frist, Jr. College of Medicine

    Established in 1999, the Education Design Showcase is a vehicle for showing off innovative — yet practical — solutions in planning, design, architecture, and construction. Thomas F. Frist, Jr. College of Medicine has been recognized with an EDS 2025 Project of Distinction award in the category of New Construction.

Digital Edition