Policy Brief Explores School Closure as a Reform Policy

East Lansing, Mich. — Closing a “low-performing” school and sending students to a “better-performing” one has been offered as a school improvement strategy, which the logic suggests will motivate schools to improve. A new policy brief released today investigates whether closing schools is an option that policymakers should pursue.

The brief, School Closure as a Strategy to Remedy Low Performance, was produced by the National Education Policy Center (NEPC), and written by Gail L. Sunderman, University of Maryland, Erin Coghlan, University of California Berkeley, and Rick Mintrop, University of California Berkeley. It was funded in part by the Great Lakes Center for Education Research and Practice.

According to the brief, the limited evidence base suggests that school closures are not a promising strategy for remedying low performance. The authors write, “School closures have at best weak and decidedly mixed benefits; at worst they have detrimental repercussions for students if districts do not ensure that seats at higher-performing schools are available for transfer students.”

In addition to reviewing the evidence base, the authors answer four overarching research questions:

  • How often do school closings occur and for what reasons?
  • What is the impact on students of closing schools for reasons of performance?
  • What is the impact of closing schools on the public school system in which closure has taken place? and
  • What is the impact of school closures on students of various ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds, and on local communities and neighborhoods?

Based on their analysis, the authors offer the following cautions: (1) Because this turnaround option is so infrequently used, policy and district actors should approach this option with caution; (2) “Closure and transfer” is a decidedly undesirable option in districts where transferring to a higher-performing school is not available; (3) School closures are especially inadvisable for middle school students, due to the shorter grade span of such schools; (4) Closing schools for any reason has costs, but closing schools solely for performance has unanticipated consequences; and (5) Closures tend to differentially affect low-income communities of color.

The authors, in their conclusion, state that school closure as a strategy for school improvement is a “high-risk/low-gain strategy that fails to hold promise for improving student achievement and non-cognitive well-being.” They continue, “In many instances, students, parents, local communities, district and state policymakers may be better off investing in persistently low-performing schools than closing them.”

Find School Closure as a Strategy to Remedy Low Performance on the web: www.greatlakescenter.org

The brief can also be found on the NEPC website: nepc.colorado.edu

About The Great Lakes Center
The mission of the Great Lakes Center for Education Research and Practice is to support and disseminate high quality research and reviews of research for the purpose of informing education policy and to develop research-based resources for use by those who advocate for education reform. Visit the Great Lakes Center Web Site at: www.greatlakescenter.org.

 

Featured

  • Thomas F. Frist, Jr. College of Medicine

    Established in 1999, the Education Design Showcase is a vehicle for showing off innovative — yet practical — solutions in planning, design, architecture, and construction. Thomas F. Frist, Jr. College of Medicine has been recognized with an EDS 2025 Project of Distinction award in the category of New Construction.

  • Fellowes Launches New 3D Modular, Product Configurators

    Contract interiors and architectural solutions provider Fellowes recently announced the launch of new 3D modular and product configurators for several of its product lines, according to a news release. The new products offer SIF file integration and pricing for the Volo, Markerboards, Sena, and Rising product lines in connection with 3D Cloud, which provides 3D product visualization and 3D digital asset management.

  • University of Kentucky Integrates New Cleaning Technology

    The University of Kentucky in Lexington, Ky., recently installed a new cleaning system designed to improve cooling efficiency on campus, according to a news release. The Facilities Management’s Utilities and Energy Management Unit installed new chiller tubes into two of the chillers at the university’s Central Utility Plant.

  • cutaway view of a modern school building, showing various rooms and zones

    Layering AI into HVAC Systems Shows Reduction in Carbon Emissions

    Heating and cooling systems are just one of the many new ways that AI can be integrated into schools. According to a new study from Schneider Electric's Sustainability Research Institute, AI-powered HVAC systems in schools can lead to significant carbon emissions savings.

Digital Edition