Assessing Your Principal Performance Evaluation System

Dallas – The George W. Bush Institute is releasing a series of guidebooks focused on Principal Talent Management (PTM) practices that districts can leverage to support school leadership.

Many school districts want to hire, support, and retain highly effective school principals, but district leaders are not always sure exactly how to change their policies or practices to make that happen. There are not enough resources available in the field to help – as a result, some schools struggle with school culture and student success.

Based on extensive research, the George W. Bush Institute School Leadership Initiative is releasing a series of guidebooks focused on Principal Talent Management (PTM) practices that districts can leverage to support school leadership. The first guidebook is centered on principal performance evaluation, an area that is often poorly implemented designed and used.

Leadership frameworks - or the common definition of highly effective school principals - are often created with little or rushed input, buy-in, or feedback from key stakeholders like teachers, principals, and support staff. Roll outs of new frameworks and accompanying rubrics require consistent messaging and lots of norming to be effective. That work is typically absent or inconsistent. 

School districts who are able to create and use effective leadership frameworks in their evaluation systems naturally see more success as they work to hire, support, and retain their principals. Successful frameworks align with state and national standards, reflect district priorities, and provide clear direction for aspiring and sitting principals. Strong frameworks aid principals in building a clearer understanding of exemplary practice and goal setting.

A robust leadership framework can also shape requirements for future principal hires. With guidelines that align directly with a school district’s needs, principals with the right talent and expertise are easily identified. And, partnerships with preparation programs, such as universities, are only strengthened as everyone is working toward a common goal.

As school districts grapple with improving principal evaluation systems, this guidebook can be a basis for best practices and research based resources. Each subsequent guidebook will provide school districts with the additional tools required to improve their Principal Talent Management system. The guidebooks include best practices, common but problematic practices, how to effectively move to best practices, districts to watch, and a list of resources available to make this tool accessible and actionable for district leaders. 

Featured

  • California School District Starts Construction on Public Safety Center

    The San Bernardino City Unified School District (SBCUSD) recently announced that construction has begun on a new public safety center that will house the district’s safety and security programs. According to a news release, the James Ramos Center for Public Safety will measure in at 17,140 square feet and contain the district’s Police Department, Office of Emergency Management, and cadet program.

  • University of Kentucky Stormwater Harvesting System Receives Award

    The Utilities and Energy Management team from the University of Kentucky recently received a Grand Award at the 2025 Engineering Excellence Awards, according to a university news release. The award from the American Council of Engineering Companies of Kentucky was for the university’s Central Utility Plant (CUP) Stormwater Harvesting System, which activated in fall 2023.

  • Tufts University Breaks Ground on Two New Residence Halls

    Tufts University in Medford, Mass., recently broke ground on two new residence halls with a total capacity of 664 beds, according to local news. The project’s ultimate goal is to expand on-campus housing and reduce pressure on the local housing market.

  • ECM Technologies Wins ‘Most Innovative Business of the Year’ Award

    HVAC preventative maintenance and efficiency solutions provider ECM Technologies was recently named the “Most Innovative Business of the Year” at the 2025 Champions of Change Awards, according to a news release. The program recognizes Arizona business leaders and organizations taking steps to make a positive impact on the state through innovative thinking and philanthropy.

Digital Edition