Saving Crucial Education Dollars

Genesee Intermediate School District (GISD) is located on Michigan’s Lower Peninsula and encompasses one large urban school district surrounded by several suburban and rural districts. About 10 years ago, GISD superintendents shared their concerns that enrollments and revenue were declining, while expenditures, such as salary increments and healthcare costs, continued to rise. Additionally, some districts chose not to fill staff vacancies as a cost-saving method, whereas other districts had difficulty filling positions that required specialized personnel.

As the result of reductions in business service staff, an increasing number of districts were receiving financial audit findings related to the segregation of cash management duties.

District leaders began considering alternative service delivery models to preserve the fiscal stability and reputation of the local districts. One such model was consolidation.

GISD manages a fiber-optic network that delivers high-speed communications between local districts and the ISD offices. That network provides a highly secure system that serves as the platform for inter-district connectivity. In addition, the districts had a common accounting software platform. With the infrastructure and common software applications in place, GISD was able to offer individual business services to its constituent districts.

Impetus for consolidation

Why would local districts consolidate business services to the ISD? Within GISD, the reasons ranged from meeting an immediate need to anticipated cost savings. As Cynthia McCain, assistant superintendent of business, describes, “One local district could not find a qualified payroll applicant willing to travel to that [rural] district, while in a second district, the business manager left unexpectedly.” In a third situation, “we walked into a district because the accountant couldn’t close the books for the audit and it was already mid-November.” In Michigan, if you do not submit the district audit and financial data by Nov. 15, state aid is withheld until the audit and figures are submitted.

On the other hand, John Fazer, superintendent of Goodrich Area Schools, says the decision was “based on personnel and dollars. The ISD provided our accounts payable services. And when our payroll person left, rather than hiring a new person, we contracted with the ISD for payroll services since they were already managing our accounts payable and receivable.”

Shared service organizational structure

As the volume of local districts requesting ISD business services grew, the GISD superintendent and board of education hired a shared services director whose sole responsibility was to manage local district operations from the ISD. To meet demand, the GISD superintendent and board also added two regional managers, each focused on a limited number of local districts and each providing customized services.

GISD Shared Services Organizational Structure 

Figure 1. GISD Shared Services Organizational Structure, 2012

What started as a typical ISD response to support a local district facing an emergency situation turned into a service delivery model and internal organization that now supports more than half of the local districts within GISD (see Figure 1).

McCain shares, “I believe flexibility is one factor that made our model successful. I designed the service models around the needs of the local district. I will work with [district administrators] to provide only the needed services.”

What started as a common ISD response to an urgent local district need has developed into a service delivery model that appears to reduce spending yet provides substantial service quality improvements over locally maintained business services; true economies of scale in action.

This article originally appeared in the issue of .

About the Author

Thomas A. DeLuca, a former finance director, is assistant professor of educational leadership and policy studies at the University of Kansas, Lawrence. He can be reached at [email protected]. This article is excerpted with permission from the February 2014 issue of School Business Affairs, published by the Association of School Business Officials International,www.asbointl.org.

Featured

  • Three U.S. Universities Install Acre Security Access Control Platform

    Cloud-native physical and digital security solutions company Acre Security recently announced that it has deployed its access control platform at three major universities in the U.S., according to a news release. Acre partnered with Atrium Campus to provide coverage for more than 69,000 students at the University of Virginia (UVA), George Mason University, and Rockhurst University.

  • University of Kansas Opens $400M Football Stadium Reconstruction

    The University of Kansas in Lawrence, Kan., recently announced that the $400-million reconstruction of David Booth Kansas Memorial Stadium is complete in time for the 2025 football season, according to a news release. The university partnered with Turner Construction Company on the project.

  • Kenall Introduces Millenium Flair Series

    In a move aimed at modernizing institutional lighting without compromising on durability or performance, Kenall has launched its new Millenium Flair series, according to the Kenall website.

  • K–12 Safety Trends Report Reveals Reliance on Training, Technology

    Wearable safety technology provider CENTEGIX recently released its 2025 School Safety Trends Report, according to a news release. The report is based on more than 265,000 incidents during the 2024–25 school year as reported through the CENTEGIX Safety Platform, used by more than 800 school districts across the U.S.

Digital Edition