NASBE Survey Finds Support for Advancing Social, Emotional, and Academic Development in Schools

  • 04/18/19

Alexandria, Va. – According to new survey research from the National Association of State Boards of Education (NASBE), influential stakeholders view social and emotional learning (SEL) favorably and are primed for conversations with state boards of education working to advance SEL policies. While most community influencers agree that SEL can produce many benefits, they also expressed reservations around standards, teacher support, and labeling of students, the survey finds.

To help state boards of education and other policymakers learn how to communicate most effectively on policies related to SEL, NASBE commissioned Edge Research to conduct a survey of community influ­encers in Connecticut, Illinois, Kansas, Michigan, and Washington to gauge their understanding of SEL and their support for embedding SEL in K-12 instruction. These five states were part of a state network convened by NASBE in 2018 to examine the successes and challenges of implementing SEL through state education systems and develop state policies that fit local contexts.

“Successful implementation of policies and standards depends on clear communication with the public and an understanding of the importance of SEL among key constituencies,” says President and CEO Robert Hull. “This study sheds light on what resonates most with those constituencies.”

The study identifies lessons for state board members as they communicate about SEL skill building and policy development:

  • Community influencers can be motivated supporters of SEL, especially when it connects with other policy issues they hold dear. While six in ten say “social and emotional learning” is a priority for schools, some components of SEL rank higher: academics (83 percent), students’ safety and security (79 percent), and preparation for the real world (76 percent). Highlighting the interconnectedness of these issues can be a powerful tool.
  • The terms “social, emotional, and academic development” (25 percent prefer from a list of 8-10 terms) and “life skills” (23 percent prefer) rally support with community influencers more effectively than does social and emotional learning (just 4 percent prefer). The label “21st century skills” has the strongest unfavorable rating, with roughly one-third of respondents disliking the term.
  • State boards should be ready to address concerns about evaluation, labeling, teacher training, and capacity. More than half of respondents are swayed by messages that suggest SEL places more burden on already overworked teachers (55 percent) and a perceived danger of student labeling, with 59 percent worrying that students will be judged or graded on their feelings.
  • How policymakers talk about SEL mat­ters. Couching policy priorities in “teaching real-world skills” (91 percent agree, reason to reinforce SEL in schools) and “making sure all children develop the social, emotional, and academic skills they need to succeed in life” (87 percent), and tying in a message of equity, resonates best with this audience.
  • Community influencers are open to state board leadership on SEL. About half of respondents were somewhat or very familiar with their state board. Six in ten trust state boards to ensure that local public schools are developing students’ social and emotional skills, more than the governor (44 percent) or other elected officials (40 percent).
  • Community groups like Boys & Girls Clubs, parent groups such as PTA, and faith-based groups are natural allies in carrying messages about SEL. Community influencers aged 18–24 are an important constituency as well. These recent students and up-and-coming parents are consistently more informed and engaged on this topic.

 “State board members recognize the inextricable connection of social and emotional well-being to academic success. As well-respected state policymakers, it is important that they be well equipped to advance state-specific SEL goals,” says NASBE President and CEO Robert Hull.

Read and share the policy update “Gauging Support for Social and Emotional Skill Building in School,” and find the full survey results here.

Featured

  • K12 Tutoring Earns Every Student Succeeds Act Level II Validation

    Personalized online tutoring service K12 Tutoring recently announced that it has received Level II validation underneath the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), according to a news release. The independently validated study provides evidence of K12 Tutoring’s role in creating positive student outcomes through effective academic intervention and research-based solutions.

  • Midland ISD Starts Construction on Two New High Schools

    The Midland Independent School District recently announced that it will break ground on two new high schools in Midland, Texas, according to a news release. The district is partnering with Pfluger Architects, Lee Lewis Construction, and Satterfield & Pontikes to create a total of over 1.5 million square feet for 8,400 students in grades 9–12.

  • Elevating Campus Maintenance: How Power Wash Drones are Transforming Educational Facilities

    As today’s campuses grow larger and more architecturally complex, keeping exteriors clean, safe, and inviting has never been tougher. Facilities leaders are under constant pressure to stretch budgets, meet safety standards, and support sustainability goals—all while tackling the stubborn challenge of exterior cleaning.

  • KI Launches K–12 Classroom Furniture Giveaway

    Contract furniture company KI recently announced the launch of its fourth-annual Classroom Furniture Giveaway, which awards $50,000 each to four K–12 educators across the U.S., according to a news release. The goal is to address decreasing student engagement and increasing teacher burnout numbers by updating learning spaces to accommodate modern needs.

Digital Edition