Expanded Choice Increases Parents' Demand for School-Quality Information

Cambridge, Mass. — A common criticism of school choice is that parents don’t know enough about their local schools to take full advantage of it. But concerns based on how informed parents are in areas where choice is limited may not tell us much about how informed they would be if they were given more options. In the latest research article from Education Next, Michael Lovenheim of Cornell University and Patrick Walsh of St. Michael’s College report results from the first study to assess how changes in the local choice environment impact parents’ demand for information about school quality, finding that the expansion of choice incentivizes parents to learn more about the educational options available to their children.

Lovenheim and Walsh analyzed over 100 million individual searches conducted from January 2010 through October 2013 on the nation’s largest school-quality website, GreatSchools.org, which provides information on school enrollment, demographics, and performance on standardized tests, as well as community reviews. The raw search data were linked to data on public school-transfer options generated by the No Child Left Behind Act and growth in the number of charter schools. The researchers focused on changes over time in search activity within each “search unit,” defined as a geographic area that potentially constitutes a school-choice zone for residents, relative to changes in the unit’s choice environment.

Among the key findings:
Eligibility to transfer schools under NCLB increased demand for information. For each 10-percentage-point increase in the number of schools in a given search area eligible for transfers, the number of GreatSchools.org searches grew by 7.2 percent.

NCLB waivers reduced search frequency. After a state obtained an NCLB waiver and school transfer options were largely eliminated, school-quality searches declined by 4 percent for each 10-percentage-point increase in the pre-waiver choice percentage. Thus, waivers reduced the effect of NCLB choice by more than half.

Charter school openings increase information-seeking by parents. Adding a charter school to an area is associated with a 5.3 percent increase in school-quality searches, providing suggestive evidence that charter school entry induces parents to obtain school-quality information and that the effect of choice on demand for information is not limited to NCLB.  

“The availability of school-quality information alone is not sufficient to lead parents to become better informed about school options,” Lovenheim and Walsh conclude. “They must also have an incentive to seek and use this information.” When given access to choices, more parents arm themselves with available information.

About the Authors: Michael F. Lovenheim is an associate professor in the Department of Policy Analysis and Management at Cornell University. Patrick Walsh is an associate professor of economics at St. Michael’s College. 

About Education NextEducation Next is a scholarly journal committed to careful examination of evidence relating to school reform, published by the Education Next Institute and the Harvard Program on Education Policy and Governance at the Harvard Kennedy School. For more information, please visit educationnext.org.

Featured

  • Case Study Highlights Texas District’s Campus Security Upgrades

    The Taft Independent School District near Corpus Christi, Texas, recently partnered with Intech Southwest Services to revamp its campus security technology system, according to a news release. Intech has released a case study on its website detailing the process that advanced the district’s technology by more than 20 years in less than three weeks.

  • Lawrence Group Announces Expansion of Student Housing Studio

    Integrated planning and design firm Lawrence Group recently announced that it has hired Nick Naeger, AIA, as the new Associate Principal / Senior Project Manager at its headquarters in St. Louis, Mo., according to a news release.

  • CSU Pueblo Installs Solar-Powered Charging Benches

    Colorado State University Pueblo (CSU Pueblo) recently announced that it has installed four solar-powered charging benches from Bluebolt Outdoor, LLC, according to a news release.

  • California Middle School Completes Two New Academic Buildings

    Sunnyvale Middle School in Sunnyvale, Calif., recently announced that construction is complete on two new classroom buildings of two stories each, according to a district news release. The new wing will house seventh- and eighth-grade students and is part of a larger campus modernization project.